Talk With Pakistan are Nothing But an Exercise in Futility

Last Updated on November 14, 2024 by Bharat Saini

Peace Between India and Pakistan: The Road Less Traveled

“Peace cannot be discussed under a shower of bullets.” – These words by former Indian President Pranab Mukherjee capture the challenges in India-Pakistan relations. Despite multiple efforts from India to foster diplomacy and peace, these initiatives have often been overshadowed by events that disrupt progress and trust. This article explores the history, challenges, and strategic decisions needed to navigate the complex relationship between India and Pakistan.

A History of Efforts and Setbacks

Since the Tashkent Agreement of 1966, India has extended multiple “hands of friendship” toward Pakistan, hoping for a breakthrough in relations. In 2015, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s surprise visit to Pakistan for Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s birthday briefly raised hopes. Unfortunately, this visit was followed by an attack on the Indian Air Force base in Pathankot, undercutting the recent gesture of goodwill. As Y.V. Chavan, Defence Minister in 1966, had once expressed, “A hand of friendship to Pakistan could be a turning point in the history of the subcontinent.” However, history has shown that peace efforts have often been met with violence rather than reciprocity.

Insight: Pakistan’s reluctance to reciprocate these efforts highlights a historical pattern where peace gestures are overlooked or disrupted by anti-India activities.

India’s Approach to Diplomacy and Peace

Indian leaders have traditionally embraced secularism and diplomacy, with former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru famously declaring, “All of us, to whatever religion we may belong, are equally the children of India.” Guided by secular ideals, India has shown restraint and patience in dealing with Pakistan, offering financial aid, creating cross-border transport services like the Delhi-Lahore bus service, and easing visa restrictions for senior citizens. These actions underscored India’s commitment to peaceful coexistence despite ongoing provocations.

Evidence and Examples of India’s Peaceful Efforts:

• Financial Assistance: India released ₹550 million to Pakistan as part of the cash balance from undivided India in 1948, symbolizing goodwill and peaceful intentions.
• Transport Services: The Samjhauta Express and Srinagar-Muzaffarabad bus links aimed to foster civilian exchanges and human connections.
• Bilateral Peace Processes: Despite numerous terror incidents, India has repeatedly opened dialogue channels, hoping for stability and peace in South Asia.

Challenge: Despite these efforts, cross-border terrorism from Pakistan-sponsored groups remains a significant barrier to peace. Attacks such as the Mumbai 26/11 incident highlight ongoing threats and Pakistan’s alleged role in supporting these groups.

Why India Must Act Tough

C. Christine Fair, a U.S. scholar on South Asian relations, has argued that failure to respond to Pakistani provocations might embolden further terrorism. Fair has advocated for a “suite of policies imposing escalating costs on Pakistan,” suggesting that diplomatic, political, and military actions could pressure Pakistan to reconsider its stance. The urgency of this tough stance was echoed following the Pathankot incident and again after the Gurdaspur and Udhampur attacks, underlining the need for India to remain vigilant.

Recommendations for Strengthening India’s Security Strategy:

• Enhanced Border Security: Strengthen surveillance, intelligence, and swift response capabilities at critical points along the India-Pakistan border.
• Strategic Partnerships: Collaborate with international allies to diplomatically isolate Pakistan for harboring anti-India militant groups.
• Mobile Military Units: Develop agile and quick-response military units capable of rapid retaliation in case of cross-border attacks.

Perspective: “Trust, but verify,” as a Russian proverb goes, aptly applies here. While India’s goodwill gestures are necessary, so is a robust strategy to counter threats.

Diplomacy Remains an Essential Tool

While a tough stance is necessary, there is still value in dialogue. Diplomacy helps avoid full-scale conflicts that could devastate both nations. For instance, despite its limitations, the Indus Waters Treaty serves as a prime example of cooperation, highlighting that constructive engagement is possible.

Additional Peace Initiatives by India:

• Sir Creek Negotiations: Resolving disputes over Sir Creek could improve mutual trust and reduce military posturing in the region.
• Promoting Trade and Economic Links: Leveraging economic cooperation could create interdependencies that discourage conflict.

Practical Approach: While efforts like the Delhi-Lahore Bus Service and Amritsar-Nankana Sahib bus links fostered connectivity, achieving long-term peace requires consistent and verifiable actions from both sides.

The Economic Case for Peace

Pakistan is one of India’s significant trade partners, with economic relations that could benefit millions. Cutting off trade ties may lead to a loss of revenue and potential growth opportunities for both nations. A peaceful relationship could encourage trade, reduce military expenses, and redirect resources toward development.

Key Economic Opportunities:

• Enhanced Trade Routes: Open road and rail networks can increase trade efficiency and boost local economies on both sides of the border.
• Investment in Infrastructure: Peace would allow both nations to invest more in education, healthcare, and infrastructure rather than defence.
• Mutual Tourism Benefits: Pakistan’s large Sikh and Hindu pilgrimage sites offer opportunities for tourism and cultural exchange, fostering goodwill.

Call for a Balanced Approach

While it is essential for India to continue extending peace gestures, it must not ignore the lessons of history. As political philosopher Niccolò Machiavelli cautioned, “War begins when you will, but they do not end when you please.” India should ensure that any peace talks are balanced with stringent security measures and vigilance.

Conclusion: Dialogue and diplomacy must be backed by actions that ensure national security. A balanced approach that combines peace efforts with security strategies could lay the foundation for a more stable and prosperous South Asia.

• • Engage in Informed Debate: Support policies that promote a balanced diplomatic and security-focused approach.
  • Stay Informed: Follow reliable sources on the latest developments in India-Pakistan relations.
  • Support Peace Initiatives: Advocate for policies that promote trade, economic cooperation, and cultural exchange to build common ground between the two nations.